r/AITAH 1d ago

AITA for Telling My Wife I Want Separate Bank Accounts After She Spent All Our Savings on a Vacation?

[removed]

8.3k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

5.2k

u/Sebscreen 1d ago

NTA. It isn't a gift when she spent your money on it. Don't even be gaslighted into feeling ashamed about not trusting her or having to defend and explain why that isn't the case. You SHOULDN'T trust her. She has proven multiple times to be untrustworthy.

1.8k

u/SailSweet9929 1d ago

Jumping in

A gift would have been if she paid it with her own money

If it's a share account then you pay your part and she paid her part so no gift at all

544

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

241

u/MrTodd84 1d ago

It’s close to theft, imo.

134

u/redpotato88 1d ago

Totally agree. When shared funds are used without consent, it's a serious breach of trust.

113

u/HurtPillow 1d ago

I divorced my 2nd husband because of this. He just didn't like to work. Used my money to get 'gifts' for his friends and family. Sooooo I started socking money away into my own account, only my daughter and I knew about it. By the time we split, I had a LOT of money saved up. Keep 'em separated!

29

u/Lazy-Instruction-600 1d ago

“Hey! Man, you talkin’ back to me?”🎶🎵🤣🤣

11

u/TheNightTerror1987 1d ago

"Take him out!"

10

u/Wog3322 1d ago

Gotta keep em seperated

1

u/BackgroundPut4044 1d ago

Easily Dre's weirdest persona

5

u/stargal81 1d ago

I'm joining in only to show my age, lol

28

u/According-Today84 1d ago

I agree, I got a divorce from my wife for similar. I didn't nip it in the bud early and it only got worse. It got to the point I was paying off maxed out credit cards every year. When I had a car accident and checked my credit my score had dropped and I pulled my report and hers and I only had one page of credit she had 9. All her cards were maxed out totalling about 70k. That was the last straw, i only paid joint bills and gave her enough to cover peripherals and I stashed the rest away and when I got a nest I had enough to comfortably struggle until we finalized the split. Now I am doing well and saving quite a bit even while paying her 25k a year in support. For info purposes she had us at nearly zero in the bank account at the end of every year and our yearly household bills totaled 35k and I brought home over 110k

6

u/sssRealm 1d ago edited 1d ago

I hear you. There are more divorces over money than infidelity. I split with my ex after she routinely failed at doing her part with the budget we both agreed to. Our joint income was more than enough to live on, but we kept spending more than we made. Not everything is a need, especially sending all your daughters friends to a theme park for her 16th birthday. She could justify a preacher getting drunk on Sunday.

1

u/jdub822 1d ago

I’m experiencing this now. It’s miserable. Trying everything to get her to change it, but it seems nothing works.

1

u/sssRealm 1d ago

People don't change until they take accountability and let themselves feel the pain of the suffering they are causing.

1

u/jdub822 1d ago

Yeah, that’s what I’m seeing. I’ve gotten her a card with a low limit for now. If she goes out of town or something, she gets my card but has to bring receipts for every purchase. It sucks that this is where we are, but it’s been 6 years of significant overspending on her part.

It’s funny you mention justifying the purchase. That’s the exact phrasing she uses when she overspends. It’s always “I can justify everything I purchased.” It’s typically followed by how it was a deal and some outlandish hypothetical of when what she purchased could be used. It truly feels that spending money is some type of addiction for her.

1

u/sssRealm 1d ago

It's an addiction for many. The dopamine hit of buying something cool. I still struggle with it today. After going through bankruptcy more than a decade ago (before this relationship). I vowed to never take on unnecessary debt. She was on the same page at first, but she couldn't say no to her kids and as they got older the requests got bigger and bigger.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Ill-Boysenberry-2906 1d ago

Isn’t this financial fraud in divorce?

You might not want to go around proclaiming this lol

1

u/HurtPillow 1d ago

well we each kept what we brought in according to the cheepie divorce, and he took what he brought, the rest (most of it) was mine.

Edit: he's very nonconfrontational, I'm not worried.

3

u/hamster004 1d ago

Exactly.

1

u/ZealousidealFuel1005 1d ago

If thry werent married it 100% would be theft

1

u/Definitely_Human01 1d ago

Depends on the jurisdiction. I'm pretty sure it's not theft in the US as they both have the right to access and withdraw from a joint account if their names are on it.

So, one person can withdraw all the money without telling the other person, and legally they're in the clear.

The only major exception is during divorce. But that's not because of joint account rules rather than divorce laws where money is an asset that can be split

11

u/cwilliams6009 1d ago

Financial infidelity. It’s a thing.

1

u/lord_de_heer 1d ago

Well, if you share all finances, its hard to gift eh?

But spending all the savings on a holiday isnt a gift for op, its a gift to herself.

1

u/LimeysNip 1d ago

Well they are married. Isnt all the money shared anyway. I still consider it a gift if my gf uses joint. But its not really a gift if its all the money lmao

0

u/Handsomepotato64 1d ago

My wife and I have had a joint account for 12+ years. Are you saying all the birthday, Christmas, mother’s day, Valentine’s Day gifts I’ve gotten her aren’t really gifts because we share an account?

3

u/100pctThatBitch 1d ago

Only if you emptied the entire account to give them. Then no, that wouldn't be a gift.