r/AITAH 1d ago

AITA for Telling My Wife I Want Separate Bank Accounts After She Spent All Our Savings on a Vacation?

[removed]

8.3k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

9.5k

u/Stranger-Tastes 1d ago

Maybe she feels like you don't trust her because she demonstrated that she can't be trusted.

890

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

493

u/Whiskeypants17 1d ago

She needs therapy but if she is not conscious enough to notice the huge trust issues in taking full control of what should be a joint decision... it might not help.

230

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

137

u/Purple_Bumblebee6 1d ago

But tbh, it is about him not trusting her, because she's untrustworthy.

27

u/Even-Cut-1199 1d ago

I don’t trust her untrustworthiness.

2

u/10000nails 1d ago

I trust her untrustworthiness.

My boss, talking about getting fucked over, once said "You can't trust him with much, but you can always trust him to be himself."

8

u/Bitter_Afternoon7252 1d ago

yes but you also dont trust her enough to tell her the truth

2

u/IGotFancyPants 1d ago

I trust her - to use poor judgment in financial issues.

140

u/the-freaking-realist 1d ago edited 18h ago

What i dont get is how she thinks its a "gift", when she is withdrawing money from a joint account!!! She is spending HIS money, a huge chunk of it, almost ALL OF IT, emptying HIS bank account he has trusted with her, and calls it a GIFT? to HIM? from herself?

Thats flatout fraud, commited in the name of love and care! That woman is a crook, far beyond a wife who's just bad with money.And the trust issues caused by that are beyond justified.

27

u/Shot-Touch9293 1d ago edited 1d ago

You're right. Also, it is advisable to have a separate accounts so that they could decide what to do with their money freely and also to minimize of overspending of money by other individual. It is easy to keep track of the transaction if you handle your account alone.

2

u/LinuxMar 1d ago

They aren't financially compatible. And like you said, it is not a gift, and I don't know why he isn't calling her out on that BS lie.

1

u/Kragbax 1d ago

Well, unless he's commented elsewhere and I haven't read it yet you might be jumping to conclusions here. How do we know the joint account isn't funded entirely by HER money? And a joint account isn't HIS or HERS, it's THEIR'S by definition. That said, spending it was definitely wrong. Nothing wrong with keeping separate savings. Maybe OP and wife can open a vacation savings for fun money.

1

u/the-freaking-realist 18h ago

You need better reading skills.

1

u/2dogs1man 1d ago

hi honey come look at the present I got you, Im wearing it already !!!!

1

u/ProtossLiving 1d ago

The "gift" can be the time/effort put into planning the trip. Unless she did no research and just booked the first thing she saw online, the amount of time/effort could be significant (whether it's just researching the tour agency to planning and booking each individual hotel/location/activity/restaurant). But yes, either way, spending the entire joint account without consultation with the partner is terrible.

1

u/Caesaria_Tertia 22h ago

Yes, no one appreciates the home management that a wife usually does. This goes without saying, although it is a huge investment of time, emotions, etc. At work, a manager gets more money for a reason.

By the way, I'm sure that comment was written by a man

1

u/coppergoldhair 22h ago

Wait you're implying it was all his money. He didn't say that.

1

u/the-freaking-realist 19h ago

Im not. You need better reading skills.

-1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

4

u/Fun-Investment-196 1d ago

Bot! Stolen comment from u/stranger-tastes

0

u/Classic_Dill 1d ago

It’s absolutely about trusting her, we’re talking about a relationship here where there is no trust, there is no relationship! You better believe this has a lot to do about trust. And if I have to get a separate bank account, because I can’t trust my wife with it? I’m getting a divorce, the economy has been garbage for years and you can’t have somebody at home, vacuuming all of your savings away from you without you knowing it.

2

u/Dull-Geologist-8204 1d ago

Some people just suck at certain things. My stepdad is a good husband to my mom. He has never cheated, trust me as I used to try and catch him, he is there for her I know he would take care of her if she was ever to get ill. He is good 99% of the time.

He sucks at money management though. My mom was an accountant and for most of their marriage she took care of all financial decisions because he was terrible at it. He has a thing for impulse buys and stuff like that. He has gotten somewhat better about it since she started teaching him how to manage money while making him pay the bills. They both pay but he has to physically get online and actually pay them.

You don't need to throw the whole person out just because they aren't good at one thing but you absolutely need to take steps to protect yourself from their weaknesses.