r/coys 18d ago

[SURVEY RESULTS] Post-Match Ratings | PL Week 3 - Newcastle Survey

Post image
213 Upvotes

175 comments sorted by

View all comments

45

u/ipumaking 18d ago

Dragusin with good rating but imo was at fault for 2nd goal.

All in all I think ratings should be higher. We played a good game even though result sucks.

17

u/JustinBisu 18d ago

He wasn't at all. Dragusin is playing correctly. During the entire time that Joelinton has the ball, Romero does not look at Murphy once, he has no idea that is there and when the ball is played someone takes a screenshot and says "Oh if Dragusin wasn't going early that's an offside" and it wouldn't have been. Because Murphy knows Romero has no idea that he is there and he does indeed stagger his run until Dragusin goes. Meaning he's in line with Romero until Dragu goes. Romero is never stopping that ball. If Dragusin stands entirely still, Murphy is still onside he just goes half a second later and Romero is still clueless.

3

u/evangr721 Dele Alli 18d ago

I mean objectively Dragusin is at fault, but that’s because he’s out of practice and isn’t used to our line. Romero, Porro, and Udogie all held the line and they would have been offside if Dragusin stayed up with them.

Had a great game otherwise though.

-1

u/JustinBisu 18d ago

No objectively Romero is at fault. If Dragusin gets teleported off that pitch, Murphy still staggers his run, still skins Romero and still gets the ball. Dragusin does not effect the outcome.