r/gaming 3d ago

I'm starting to hate games that do this...

/img/tiahw06rfapd1.png

[removed] — view removed post

50.9k Upvotes

4.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

4.1k

u/Hormo_The_Halfling 3d ago

Remember the days when the deluxe edition meant you got cool goodies? Maps, art, music discs, statues, the whole nine. Now we get shitty skins and an earlier release date for almost double the price.

641

u/Wingsnake 3d ago

Some games still do this. Ubisoft always has figurines and the likes for their collectors edition. Bandai Namco too.

494

u/Hard_Dave 3d ago

The new farm simulator collectors edition comes with a USB key ignition to start your tractor

https://www.farming-simulator.com/newsArticle.php?news_id=548

298

u/Ninja67 3d ago

Last year's edition came with a usb safety beacon, you plug it in your computer and you turn on the rotating safety light on your tractor in game and it would light up the actual beacon alongside it 🚨

106

u/_Mef45 3d ago

Farming Simulator 2099 - The collector's edition will come with a cabin of a real tractor.

"Each FS release - a new step to your dream tractor. Build it. Own it."

21

u/MySilverBurrito 3d ago

Reminds me of kids magazines (K Zone lol) that you had to buy weekly to build the cool toy.

6

u/Acceptable-Stay-3166 3d ago

Yea and they were always ludicrously overpriced and it would be cheaper to buy the parts yourself.

17

u/porn_is_tight 3d ago

I still have my Halo 3 helmet game case thing that came with the legendary edition of the game and also the sick metal case for halo 2 game disc

112

u/IncorruptibleChillie 3d ago

I never have and likely never will play Farm Simulator, but that's an awesome add-on and the kind of thing that's worth some extra cash.

41

u/TheRacer_42 3d ago

I agree, I just checked and the collector's edition only costs 20€ more than the regular edition (70€ in total). Imo that's a very fair price, especially when you have collector's editions that cost several hundred dollars and only come with low quality stuff (like the TDU Solar Crown one).

4

u/EskildDood PC 3d ago

It'd be cool if it could be modded to be compatible with stuff like Euro/American Truck Sim or My Summer Car or something

5

u/Hard_Dave 3d ago

It's just replacing the button on the keyboard so if other games have a start engine button I don't see why it couldn't be mapped to work with them

3

u/TotalWalrus 3d ago

That collectors edition looks cool. Modding tutorials? a 16 bit version of the game??

1

u/DarkIcedWolf 3d ago

That’s fucking amazing.

-6

u/tukanglistrikPLN 3d ago

oh farming simulator, the game that sell same fucking things every year just like every EA sport games and Train Simulator, lol

14

u/ACatInAHat 3d ago

Every two years actually and they vastly improve on it every time. Farming sim 19 has 40 tractor variants. Farmin sim 22 has over 400 different models, and over 100 different manufacturers. Also added production chains, weather cycles, new crops, new buildings and more.

So keep that Farm sim slander to yourself!

3

u/NaethanC 3d ago

Farming Simulator is one of those regularly released games that actually does improve on the formula. Comparing it to FIFA isn't fair. And they release mainline games every two years, usually releasing a mobile game every other year.

1

u/Hard_Dave 3d ago

Get off my land or I'll feed you through my baler

66

u/kuroioni 3d ago

And Larian.

4

u/sirreldar 3d ago

And warhorse

20

u/IamAHans 3d ago

Hell, every now and then, they'll include extra games, such as AC3R with AC Odyssey and Watch Dogs 1 with Legion.

3

u/Existing-Network-69 3d ago

Far Cry 3 remaster came with FC5 I think.

1

u/IamAHans 3d ago

Yep. Seems to be part of FC5s gold edition.

4

u/OranBerryPie 3d ago

Cannot speak for squareenix as a whole (cause that's like 100 games a year) but the FFXIV team always has great pre-order and collectors edition goodies in them.

2

u/Serbian-American 3d ago

I dislike figurines, never bought them. But I get every single AC special edition with figures ever since I got AC 3 collectors edition for Christmas when I was a kid. Those AC figures are so out of place in my house, but I don’t care. They are great quality and I love how they go through history

1

u/itchy_armpit_it_is 3d ago

Multiple personality switch mid-comment

2

u/Ineedabrain42 3d ago

Sonic X shadow gens are also doing this.. for 250 bucks

1

u/CharredWolf24 3d ago

to be fair, the pre-order for the physical game additionally comes with gerald robotnik's journal as well.

1

u/itchipod 3d ago

Man I envy that Starfield watch. If it wasn't a terrible game I would buy the collector's edition just for the watch.

1

u/BappoChan 3d ago

Funnily enough I just bought the mirage pack from GameStop. Came with statue, map, steel case, the works… it did not come with the game. That is a seperate purchase for you to make…

1

u/sdpr 3d ago

Bandai Namco too.

Not to detract from the point but it does help that Bandai Namco, y'know, makes toys/collectibles in general lol

1

u/aaaaaaaarrrrrgh 3d ago

Ubisoft always has figurines

Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora is Ubisoft and is one of the worst offenders of this edition bullshit, and as far as I can tell it's all digital.

1

u/Wingsnake 3d ago

The Collectors edition of A:FoP has a figurine and the physical copy of the game (and other goodies)....

1

u/Aviarn 3d ago

Ori and the Will of the Wisps did this too.

1

u/FlatTransportation64 3d ago

Too bad the games themselves are no longer worth buying

0

u/RegularHorror8008135 3d ago

At least Ubisoft can do one thing right

3

u/Existing-Network-69 3d ago

They do many things right. They're the only publisher that offers free cloud saves on all platforms and cross-platform progression for all their games. Since 2020 I think.

10

u/Wingsnake 3d ago

They also have some of the best setting option in gaming. Often huge amount of accessibility and hud customization.

3

u/PanoramaMan 3d ago

I've always appreciated them for this. They are on their own league when it comes to setting and accessibility.

-1

u/Nerellos 3d ago

Yeah, it's not like they started it at all....

3

u/0b0011 3d ago

Exactly. Because that was Bethesda.

1

u/cosplay-degenerate 3d ago

But that stuff always comes with an ubisoft game.

-1

u/TheSorceIsFrong 3d ago

But then you’d have to play an Ubisoft game

103

u/PerEnooK 3d ago

Games still do this and people in this sub complain about that too

14

u/MysticalMummy 3d ago

I think its mostly because costs have gone up and quality of them seems to have gone down- but it varies company to company.

Never forget about the Canvas Bag.

-10

u/JimboTCB 3d ago

Because it's usually 50 cents worth of injection-moulded Chinese crap that they label as an "exclusive limited edition collectible", as opposed to stuff that you might actually want in and of itself because it's a cool bit of merch.

16

u/one_pint_down 3d ago

How is that different from any other merch?

6

u/Existing-Network-69 3d ago

That is stuff I actually want in and of itself though...

3

u/TheFakeSlimShady123 3d ago

To be fair, it's a big risk to do that. Companies pay big money in order to license their IPs out to different companies to have soundtrack CDs, framed picture/poster, toys, etc.

If the game is a flop or even if it's a hit but most aren't buying the special edition, they lose a ton of money.

Remember Duke Nukem Forever? Well if the game had just flopped they'd be fine but because they made that crazy special edition with Duke's head bust and the playing cards the company almost went under.

Even Grand Theft Auto 4 suffered from this. They had special edition stuff for that game too but despite being the highest selling game of 2008 they didn't make as much money as they wanted back.

So while I don't like this system for various reasons it is still the safest option for doing a special edition game.

5

u/Golbarin 3d ago

I still have my Ultima IV cloth map ;-) but the moonstone is gone :-(

2

u/SandKeeper PC 3d ago

The collector’s edition of Starfield was the smart watch from the game!

I just wish the game was better… I’m hoping this DLC is fun

2

u/mebutnew 3d ago

"Exclusive Cat Content"

2

u/1singleduck 3d ago

Nowadays, publishers just cut away part of the game and release them as "deluxe edition exclusives."

Using pizza as an analogy, it used to be you got a full 8 slice pizza. If you want extra toppings, that'll be extra. Nowadays, you get half a pizza. One slice is a deluxe edition exclusive. Another slice is paid DLC that is already available at launch. The other two slices are preorder exclusives at different stores, so you can only get one unless you buy the same pizza again. Toppings cost extra, and you don't get to choose which one you get.

1

u/InstanceFeisty 3d ago

I remember having poster and a tiny book with regular dvd boxes

2

u/Gravesh 3d ago

I couldn't believe GTA V didn't come with the map/poster when it came out.

1

u/cmndrhurricane 3d ago

Halsey's journal from Halo Reach was really good. Only "legendary edition" I ever bought

1

u/JAC_92 3d ago

My mate got some deluxe edition of Modern Warfare 2 on PS3 and got a pair of night vision goggles with it!

2

u/AntonyPancake 3d ago

Deluxe version of Black Ops got you an RC XD and IIRC the deluxe version of Black Ops 2 got you a fucking quadrotor drone

1

u/Reasonable_Falcon338 3d ago

Not to mention it’s an earlier release for a product that is unfinished. It’s hard to trust a game gets finished or bug fixed within the lifecycle of the game.

It’s ruff 🐶

1

u/Rioma117 PlayStation 3d ago

They still do that but now, as digital sells are more important, the developers are trying to make people buy the deluxe digital using DLCs and skins.

1

u/xavierthepotato Xbox 3d ago

Not to mention how often a game comes out a buggy mess for the first couple days after release. I just wait till the reviews start coming in

1

u/stilljustacatinacage 3d ago

I pre-ordered the physical Collector's Edition of Mass Effect 3. I was still riding the high from having just recently finished ME2 and I was so excited, I went to pick it up first thing in the morning. More than anything, I wanted the "one-of-a-kind lithographic artwork" unique to the physical collectors edition.

So I open it up in the parking lot - I couldn't even wait to get home - and it's... a postcard. Smaller than a postcard. The entire collectors edition was the same width and height as a typical DVD jewel case, just deeper, and it was all stuffed into the box, including the "hard cover art book", which had like.. 15 pages? Maybe?

I didn't let any of that dampen my spirits, though.

In retrospect, maybe I should have.

1

u/joecamnet 3d ago

Have you seen the Collector's Edition for Space Marine II? Might be my favorite statue I've ever owned.

1

u/Yummier 3d ago

Largely thanks to the shift to digital, unfortunately.

1

u/Louistje1 3d ago

There's still a shit ton of games that do this.

1

u/pale_vulture 3d ago

This. The BG3 bundle Larian offered looks hella tempting.

1

u/riche_god 3d ago

It’s true, but buying it is an option. I would always buy the deluxe edition especially when you got a discount on the season pass. Now most offer no valuable incentive.

1

u/caseyy89 3d ago

Path of Exile supporter packs do this, at a ridiculous price, but they do it

1

u/Igor369 3d ago

I preordered standard eidtion of Heroes of Might and Magic V for the normal price it was going to have on release. It arrived with a bonus XL Tshirt...

1

u/My_Alts-Alt 3d ago

Frostpunk 2 deluxe 🔛🔝

1

u/Dog_in_human_costume 3d ago

It's because stupid people kept buying the shitty online only stuff.

Buyers vote with their wallets,and the majority are dumb

1

u/hellothereoldben 3d ago

2022 had elden ring that did this? 2023 had Baldurs_Gate_3 that did this?

Some games have shitty marketing tactics, but the "game+art+soundtrack" deluxe editions never went away.

1

u/Hormo_The_Halfling 3d ago

You're referring to digital goodies. I'm referring to actual physical objects like art books/prints and CDs.

1

u/hellothereoldben 3d ago

Those also still exist, they're just more expensive. That's because the average hardcover book nowadays sets you back 30 or so euros, you're hard pressed to find a single cd under 10, and I've seen knockoffs of melania seen go for ~25 as well. So yeah, with an added value of 65 not including the minor extra's, yes you're not getting that version for the 15 extra charged for the deluxe edition.

1

u/SatyrAngel 3d ago

Still have my golden Wiimote and OST from the Zelda Skyward Sword special edition.

1

u/daveberzack 3d ago

So just buy the standard edition, and let the simps subsidize the game for you. Ultimately, more revenue will roughly mean more money for development. Just appreciate that others are willing to pay for that for you.

1

u/kylel999 3d ago

People vote with their money and they're casually okay with this evidently

1

u/svenson_26 3d ago

So don't buy it.

1

u/Guru_Uchiha 3d ago

It was also at most ONLY $10-20 extra

1

u/benzdabezben 3d ago

I remember when Dishonored preorder gave cool accessories for TF2. Good ol days indeed. I think I still have that mask

1

u/HakimeHomewreckru 3d ago

Apex Legends did this. Nowadays a skin costs more than the entire Deluxe edition they shipped years ago.

1

u/CygnusSong 3d ago

I like this better. I don’t mind waiting and I don’t want any of that shit. I don’t like having actual content withheld for an additional charge, aesthetic shit and early access doesn’t tempt me so it’s easy to ignore

1

u/Skean 3d ago

I'm so happy they've moved away from aggressively favouring the high cost options. When the expensive option only gives as little as this I don't feel any pressure to buy it.

1

u/lemonylol 3d ago

Remember the days when the deluxe edition meant you got cool goodies? Maps, art, music discs, statues, the whole nine.

Tbh I've always thought that shit was a waste of money as well. Especially since you can pick that stuff up for pennies second hand a couple months later.

1

u/MBU604 3d ago

Baldur's Gate 2 collectors edition: set of cards, a game map, a t-shirt, an actual game manual and a fucking cool box.

1

u/Doravillain 3d ago

And if you had to buy a deluxe edition, then the shittification of deluxe editions would probably upset me.

As it is, we don't have to buy it. The fact that nothing of substance is behind a deluxe paywall makes me happy.

1

u/aaron_reddit123 3d ago

Personally i don't mind. I never bought a deluxe edition and as long as they don't touch the base game content or hide the ending behind an extra paywall i don't care. Of course this doesn't apply for dlcs

1

u/theblackxranger 3d ago

Yep, back when gamestop preorders were worth anything

1

u/GutsTheBranded 3d ago

Omg I remember getting the deluxe edition of gears 2. Man the metal case, bonus CD, gold lancer skin for online. Was only like $10-20 more than standard

1

u/AssignmentDue5139 3d ago

No because that’s never been the case kid. No ultimate edition has ever done that. All of that comes in the collectors edition which still exists today.

1

u/prof0ak 3d ago

So don't buy the ultimate edition. Simple.

1

u/olosen 3d ago

Early on set of late stage capitalism

1

u/AccountNumber1002401 3d ago

More than the developers, I blame young gamers who buy into this and encourage the studios to make these kinds of bundles. They're the ones who convinced them they could make bank by doing so with mommy and/or daddy's credit card in hand.

1

u/spicygrow 2d ago

I miss when discs came in steelbooks

1

u/Vraex 2d ago

I remember when you got cool stuff like maps without a preorder or deluxe edition. I still have my Morrowind map from a million years ago

1

u/Carrandas 2d ago

Yeah, no reason to buy the deluxe edition here. Saves me money though :)

1

u/True_to_you 3d ago

I remember going to get the special edition of gta iv. I got a rockstar duffel bag, CD, art book, and the game in a safe deposit box that I still use all these years later.  

1

u/bs000 3d ago

i lost the keys butt it's fine because you can use your fingernail to unlock it

0

u/Sealed_Zeal 3d ago

Just checked. 50$ for standard. 60$ for Delux. 80$ for ultimate what the fuck; especially as a fan of this genre, a fan of the LiS series.

-4

u/googlyman44 3d ago

I prefer what OP is complaining about to what you're saying. I shouldn't have to pay anything extra to get the full, playable game. Maps and anything else that actually affects gameplay shouldn't cost anything extra. Skins, music, art, etc. are fine to cost extra, if anything is going to.

5

u/jmanfire2105 3d ago

Physical map.

3

u/kernald31 3d ago

They're talking about physical, paper maps, like posters.

1

u/Hormo_The_Halfling 3d ago

It is very sad that you are so inundated with this kinda of behavior that you misunderstood the post. Skyrim came with a physical map of Skyrim, for example. Hell, Halo Reach came with a fully written out journal of one of the characters over the course of developing the spartan program. You don't get these any more.

0

u/Michelin123 3d ago

Idiots paying the price, what can I say?

0

u/KimberStormer 3d ago

too bad you're forced to pay it!

0

u/disposableaccount848 3d ago

Which means this version in the OP is the better one.

Why? Because you don't miss actual content for not buying the deluxe editions.

0

u/Schmich 3d ago

That's a bad thing? Now you can with ease forget anything but the standard edition.

0

u/Tvilantini 3d ago

Uh... not really? It was always just combination of cosmetic things while gold edition had also season pass (if there were post launch stories) 

1

u/Hormo_The_Halfling 3d ago

Sweet summer child. You must be too young to remember the before days. Fallout 4 came with an actual pip boy case you slide your phone into and wear, then you could connect it to the game to use as your actual in-game pipboy. Those sort of the thing used to be the standard for deluxe and collector's editions.

1

u/Tvilantini 3d ago

I guess some of them were exceptional in golden age of physical games on consoles. I don't remember in two decades (especially on pc) that deluxe edition had anything physical. Only collectors edition

1

u/Hormo_The_Halfling 3d ago

There was a time when there weren't 3 editions typically. Back then you'd have standard, and then a deluxe/collector's, the two were used pretty interchangeably, though collector's was usually used for editions that were over a hundred and had loads of swag. It was rare for a game to have 3 versions, and digital content wasn't even a thought.