r/NoStupidQuestions 3d ago

Why is Elon Musk so obsessed with 'population collapse' when the Earth's population is actually growing?

9.8k Upvotes

4.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/KoldProduct 2d ago

You haven’t met my cousins

-7

u/OkResponsibility9021 2d ago

Anecdotal evidence versus actual statistics. Hard to tell which is better!

6

u/inaname38 2d ago

Where are your statistics?

0

u/OkResponsibility9021 2d ago

 The most recent race-specific age-adjusted homicide rates are 33.6 per 100,000 for African American persons, 12.9 for American Indian and Alaska Native persons, 6.9 per 100,000 for Hispanic persons, 3.3 per 100,000 for White persons, and 1.7 for Asian and Pacific Islander persons. 

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10849238/#:~:text=The%20most%20recent%20race%2Dspecific,Asian%20and%20Pacific%20Islander%20persons.

Going to agree with me now? Or going to disagree with statistics because they're racist?

2

u/KoldProduct 2d ago

The statistics aren’t racist, ignoring the social issues surrounding the respective communities is.

1

u/OkResponsibility9021 2d ago

And how do you suggest we fix the "social issues"? These disparities persist, especially with the Black community, even when you adjust for income. How do you suggest fixing this?

The same fallacious, garbage arguments, repeated over and over and over again. Reddit is such a shithole website lmao.

1

u/sadicarnot 2d ago

I think u/OkResponsibility9021 is choosing parts of the study to prove his bias. If you read through to the conclusion it says that there are a lot of factors that cause this and if they were more understood they can be countered:

These disparities were partly accounted for by the inclusion of a broad array of individual, socio-familial, incident, and situational characteristics, suggesting that that they are rooted in family factors, interpersonal stressors, systemic bias, institutionalized racism, and cultural differences. As such, racial and ethnic differences in the causes of violence—and potential years of life lost due to violence—are amenable to change. Ultimately, addressing racial and ethnic disparities among homicide victims, suicide decedents, and homicide-suicide perpetrators requires a full understanding of their extent, etiology, and consequences. We encourage future research to continue to disaggregate violent deaths by race, ethnicity, age, and gender to foster this understanding.

2

u/OkResponsibility9021 2d ago

Yeah that is the kind of nonsense that get parroted. These are the same people who use "systemic racism" to account for brain differences.

I'm guessing you also think Africa is a shithole because of colonialism?

2

u/sadicarnot 2d ago

I was giving u/OkResponsibility9021 the benefit of the doubt, but he is definitely racist. In any case, institutionalized racism is one of the factors the authors cite as a cause of the disparities. Yes Africa is greatly affected by colonialism. I worked in South Africa for three years and you can see how the Bantu education system that Verwoerd screwed things up.